I’ve had multiple conversations with friends about really bad management they’ve recently experienced. While such talks are always disturbing, the most unfortunate thing is they’re all too common — as we might expect in a management landscape where data consistently shows only around 30% of employees are strongly committed to their companies.
In these recent conversations, the problematic management behavior that was described often contained variations on a theme. I’ve distilled it to four regrettably common types of dysfunction. So here we go — these highly ineffective managers:
Rarely communicate. Open, transparent communication is the foundation on which the house of management is built, and when a house lacks a solid foundation, the whole structure rests on shaky ground. In my many years in management I never met a good manager who wasn’t also a good communicator. Managers who prefer to keep to themselves rather than interacting regularly with their troops simply aren’t well-suited for the role. At the rare times when communication from such reclusive managers does occur, it’s usually negative in tone (what I call “Gotcha management”), pointing out a problem.
Take no responsibility. Good managers take responsibility for their actions. As the old leadership saying states, “Give credit, take responsibility.” It goes with the territory. (Just as an aside, it’s interesting to note that a chronic unwillingness to take personal responsibility is a key attribute of our president.) The unsatisfactory managers I’ve recently discussed were all too willing to “throw others under the bus” to deflect negative attention from themselves.
Have the scruples of a timber rattler. OK, that phrase may be a trifle harsh. But as the point above suggests, weak unprincipled management is invariably less concerned with “doing the right thing” for an organization than with protecting their own career interests. Studies show that narcissists in particular are likely overrepresented in management, and narcissists are characterized by arrogant behavior, grandiose opinions of themselves and a marked lack of empathy for others. A highly unproductive constellation of attributes for management.
Are far more concerned with their own career than yours. This was another common theme in my recent management dialogues. Selfish managerial behavior, in short. “It’s not about you” was the way I once wrote about this phenomenon — the best managers focus on the needs of others. And by so doing they get the best work out of others, which of course is what productive management is all about.
Taken alone, any one of these four traits can give an employee
My counsel, if you’re an employee confronted with a manager displaying this behavior? Sorry to say, but deeply ingrained patterns are unlikely to change. It’s always advisable to maintain professional demeanor and performance, but at the same time I’d begin looking elsewhere. Your most meaningful vote will probably be with your feet.
Reader thoughts on this topic? Always interested to hear your perspectives…